CNIL fines ten French local authorities over cybersecurity and GDPR violations

CNIL fines ten French local authorities over cybersecurity and GDPR violations

Key takeaways

The French Data Protection Authority (CNIL) has imposed fines on ten local authorities and a public institution for failing to ensure the security of personal data and to conduct data protection impact assessments (DPIAs). These decisions highlight the responsibilities of public authorities regarding cybersecurity and the importance of overseeing outsourced IT services.

 

On November 9, 2026, the CNIL announced ten fines against local authorities and a public institution, ranging from €3,000 to €20,000. These fines followed inspections conducted in 2025, when cybersecurity in local government was among the CNIL's enforcement priorities. (1)

The violations primarily involved inadequate information system security measures and the failure to conduct impact assessments for certain high-risk processing activities. These fines highlight several key issues regarding security responsibilities for public authorities and their IT service providers.

 

1. Failures to comply with data security obligations

1.1 Security obligations under the GDPR

Local authorities process substantial amounts of personal data on a daily basis, covering a wide range of areas, including civil registration, social benefits, financial information, children's data, and public service management.

As data controllers, they must ensure a level of security appropriate to the risks associated with these processing activities.

Article 32 of the GDPR, concerning the security of processing, requires controllers and processors to implement appropriate technical and organizational measures, taking into account the nature of the data, the risks involved, the state of the art, and the costs of implementation. These measures are intended to ensure the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of data, as well as the resilience of systems. They may include data encryption, access management, backup and restoration procedures, and regular security testing.

1.2 Security deficiencies identified by the CNIL

The inspections revealed several deficiencies in information system security.

a) Inadequate access and authorization management: Remote access arrangements for public employees presented weaknesses, particularly for accounts with elevated privileges. The CNIL identified a lack of multifactor authentication for certain administrators, as well as the use of insufficiently strong passwords or passwords stored under inappropriate conditions.

The inspections also revealed excessive access privileges granted to IT service providers. Some had permanent access to networks without requiring specific authorization for each intervention. In other cases, several employees shared the same account.

These practices increase the risk of unauthorized access and make it more difficult to identify the individuals responsible for operations performed on the systems.

b) Deficiencies in network monitoring and protection: The CNIL identified shortcomings in the logging and analysis of IT events, limiting the local authorities' ability to detect abnormal activity promptly.

Inadequate network segmentation, which could facilitate the spread of an intrusion, and the use of obsolete operating systems that were no longer supported constituted additional vulnerabilities. The CNIL also found that some of the local authorities inspected had experienced personal data breaches that could have been prevented through appropriate security measures.

c) Failure to formalize security requirements before deploying certain systems: Several public authorities had failed to complete the security accreditation process for certain information systems, although this was required under the French General Security Framework (Référentiel général de sécurité, or RGS). (2)

The accreditation procedure established by the RGS allows the relevant public authority to assess the risks associated with a system and formally document its decision to accept residual risks before the system becomes operational. Separate from the obligations under Article 32 of the GDPR, this procedure contributes to managing the security of the systems concerned.

These findings demonstrate that information system security does not depend solely on technical safeguards. It also requires an appropriate organizational framework and regular risk monitoring.

 

2. Failures to conduct data protection impact assessments (DPIAs)

2.1 When is a DPIA required?

Article 35 of the GDPR requires a data protection impact assessment (DPIA) to be conducted before implementing processing likely to result in a high risk to the rights and freedoms of individuals. This assessment evaluates the necessity and proportionality of the processing, the risks involved, and the measures intended to mitigate them.

Several criteria must be considered when determining whether a DPIA is required, including:

  • the processing of sensitive data or data of a highly personal nature;
  • the processing of data concerning vulnerable individuals, such as children;
  • systematic monitoring of individuals;
  • large-scale data processing; and
  • the use of innovative technologies.

As a general rule, the presence of two criteria indicates a high risk. However, depending on the characteristics of the processing, a single criterion may be sufficient to require a DPIA. (3)

As a reminder, the CNIL has published lists of processing operations for which a DPIA is required or, conversely, is not required.

2.2 Compliance failures identified

Several local authorities were fined for failing to conduct DPIAs before deploying systems presenting high risks.

Two categories of processing activities were involved.

a) Online school and extracurricular services: Platforms allowing parents to manage their children's school and extracurricular activities process information concerning minors, who are considered vulnerable individuals, as well as highly personal data, such as bank account details. The combination of these characteristics warrants a prior risk assessment covering, among other aspects, access privileges, data access arrangements, and security safeguards.

b) Video surveillance systems in public areas: Video surveillance systems may involve systematic monitoring on a large scale of a publicly accessible area, a situation expressly addressed by Article 35 of the GDPR. Depending on the purposes pursued, the system may fall within the scope of the GDPR or the specific regime established by the French Data Protection Act (Loi Informatique et Libertés) for processing activities relating to law enforcement and criminal justice. (4)

The DPIA must assess the risks associated with the collection, recording, storage, and conditions governing access to video footage.

In both cases, the impact assessment serves as a preventive measure. It must be conducted before processing begins, rather than being used merely to bring an already operational system into compliance.

 

3. What lessons can local authorities and their IT service providers learn?

3.1 For local authorities and public administrations: organizing and monitoring compliance

a) Ensuring the security of processing activities: These fines demonstrate that public authorities must ensure the security of the processing activities for which they are responsible, including when technical operations are outsourced to third-party providers. This responsibility requires identifying processing activities, defining access privileges, monitoring security measures, and verifying the conditions under which service providers access and operate systems.

Digital projects must also undergo a risk assessment from the design stage. Where processing presents a high risk, a DPIA must be conducted before implementation.

b) The role of the DPO: Under Article 37 of the GDPR, local authorities are required to designate a data protection officer (DPO).

The DPO informs and advises the organization regarding its obligations, monitors compliance with the GDPR, and provides advice concerning DPIAs. It is essential to involve the DPO in digital projects involving the processing of personal data from the design stage and to enable the DPO to work with the various departments concerned.

3.2 For IT service providers: defining service arrangements and securing system access

The deficiencies identified also concern the conditions under which IT service providers (software vendors, systems integrators, maintenance providers, and hosting providers) access local authorities' systems. When acting as processors within the meaning of the GDPR, these providers must implement security measures appropriate to the processing activities and comply with the controller's documented instructions.

Particular attention must be paid to remote access. Access management should prioritize individual user accounts, restricted privileges, strong authentication, and activity logging.

Service providers must also supply the technical information necessary for risk assessments and assist local authorities in conducting DPIAs, in accordance with applicable obligations and the agreed contractual services.

The allocation of responsibilities must be clearly defined: the local authority remains responsible for its processing activities, while the service provider is accountable for its own obligations as a processor. These requirements must be reflected in IT contracts. In particular, contracts should specify the conditions governing system access, the respective responsibilities of the parties, the security measures required, and the procedures for reporting security incidents.

 

The ten fines announced by the CNIL illustrate the consequences of inadequate information system protection and the failure to assess risks before implementing processing activities. The fines, ranging from €3,000 to €20,000, were imposed under the simplified enforcement procedure. The decisions have not been made public.

Beyond the financial penalties, these enforcement actions demonstrate that GDPR compliance requires an ongoing security policy, a clear allocation of responsibilities, and rigorous contractual oversight of outsourced services.

The CNIL has announced that further proceedings involving local authorities are underway.

* * * * * * * * * * *

(1) CNIL, November 9, 2026, “Cybersécurité des collectivités territoriales : la CNIL prononce dix sanctions” (Cybersecurity in local government: CNIL imposes ten fines).

(2) https://cyber.gouv.fr/reglementation/reglementation-identite-confiance-numerique/securite-echanges-voie-electronique/referentiel-general-de-securite/

(3) CNIL, “L'analyse d'impact relative à la protection des données (AIPD)” (Data protection impact assessments).

(4) French Act No. 78-17 of January 6, 1978, on Information Technology, Data Files and Civil Liberties, as amended, Article 90.

Bénédicte DELEPORTE

Avocat

 

Deleporte Wentz Avocat

www.dwavocat.com

 

November 2026


Mots clés :

accessibilité numérique (8) adwords (3) ai (42) anssi (9) arcep (5) arcom (25) audiovisuel (4) audit (6) base de données (5) bitcoin (1) blockchain (8) cbpr (9) cgv (2) chine (1) cjue (3) cloud computing (3) cnil (34) commerce (6) communication (9) compliance (55) confidentialité (5) conformité (37) consommateurs (5) contrat (12) contrefaçon (10) cookies (8) copyright (5) cryptologie (4) csa (1) cybercriminalité (5) cybersquatting (3) data (3) data controller (8) data privacy (28) data privacy framework (2) dma (4) données à caractère personnel (24) données personnelles (46) dpf (2) droit d'auteur (11) dsa (18) e-commerce (19) e-consommateurs (3) enfance (9) etats-unis (6) eu (30) europe (28) formation (7) fraude (3) gdpr (47) google (4) gpai (9) hébergeur (6) ia (27) ico (1) informatique (15) informatique et libertés (4) intelligence artificielle (25) internet (40) jeu vidéo (3) liberté d'expression (3) logiciel (19) loi informatique et libertés (6) loi sren (6) marque (4) métavers (3) méthode agile (2) monnaie électronique (1) moteur de recherche (7) nda (1) nft (4) nom de domaine (1) numérique (18) originalité (5) privacy shield (2) propriété intellectuelle (16) protection des données (20) publicité (6) référencement (4) réglementation (13) réseau (2) réseaux sociaux (13) responsabilité (13) responsable du traitement (19) rgpd (39) robotique (9) rpa (6) salariés (5) santé (1) santé publique (1) sécurité (9) security (5) singapour (9) site web (5) us (3) vie privée (25)